9. Integrated plant protection (IPM) |
The Principles of Integrated Plant Protection have to be applied. Preventive (indirect) measures and observations in the field on pest, disease and weed status must have been considered before intervention with direct plant protection measures takes place
|
9.1 Prevention (= indirect plant protection)
|
The prevention and/or suppression of key pests, diseases and weeds can be achieved or supported among other options especially by the:
- Choice of appropriate resistant/tolerant cultivars.
- Use of an optimal replanting interval or similar strategy to prevent diseases and weakness.
- Use of adequate cultivation techniques, (e.g. green cover, pruning, removal of infected prunings, alternate mowing); pruning not only removes dead tissues but also allows proper ventilation and more effective spray coverage.
- Use of balanced fertilisation (especially low nitrogen input) and irrigation practices.
- Protection and enhancement of important natural enemies by adequate plant protection measures.
- Utilisation of ecological infrastructures inside and outside production sites to enhance a supportive conservation biological control of key pests by antagonists.
IP guidelines must (see 8.1.3.c) describe a basic selection of preventive measures that have to be implemented.
Drosophila suzukii (spotted-wing drosophila): Sanitation practices (in particular unmarketable and waste fruit removal and destruction during and post-harvest) are necessary to reduce the use of insecticides.
|
The prevention and/or suppression of key pests and diseases should be supported among other options especially by:
- Hygiene, proper disinfection or cleaning of buildings, clothes, hands, tools, booms, tanks, sprayers and machines is recommended.
- Preventing the carryover of organisms which transmit a phytohygenic damage potential, when spread.
Examples: Weeds like Cyperus esculentus or Rorippa palustris, nematodes like Globodera rostochiensis, fungi like Plasmodiophora brassicae with machines.
- Choice of appropriate resistant/tolerant cultivars;
- Removal of sources of infestation or infection (such as leaves, canes, dead plants, weeds, fruits) should be applied as far as practically possible.
- Achieving early installation of predatory mites and insects by using supplementary feed such as pollen, Ephestia spp. eggs, etc.
- Manage the humidity to avoid the effects of dry climate, which can exacerbate spider mite attacks.
- Drosophila suzukii (spotted-wing drosophila): In order to minimize damage, preferably select cultivars that ripen before population buildup. Early harvest and/or increasing the harvest frequency reduce the exposure of fruits to the pest. Avoid water stagnation in and around the fields, keep the grass mowed under the plants, black plastic mulch can create a hot/dry microclimate, unsuitable for D. suzukiidevelopment. Use pruning and canopy management in order to limit humid shaded areas in the foliage and facilitate the exposure of most of the fruits to sunlight.
- The use of insect-proof nets around the perimeter of crops could be considered, with an awareness of the effects on immigration natural enemies and pollinators.
|
9.2 Risk assessment and monitoring
|
Interventions to control pests, diseases and weeds must be based on adequate monitoring methods and tools to determine whether and when to apply direct control measures.
Robust and scientifically sound warning, forecasting and early detection/diagnosis systems (decision support systems) as well as sound threshold values are essential components for decision making.
The official forecasts of pest and/or disease risks, or officially established threshold levels defined for the region must be taken into account before treatments.
Regionally adapted Decision Support Systems (DSS) for pests, diseases and weeds help to justify control and to optimize the timing.
Monitoring by observation or pheromone trapping (follow individual recommendations per trap type).
|
Empirical threshold values should be replaced by more scientifically sound approaches, like DSS, and expert systems.
In berries, most of pests and diseases have a rapid lifecycle (spider mites, thrips, aphids), hence frequent monitoring of the crop is very important. This consists of, at least weekly, checking of the crop for possible pest and diseases on plants, on colored traps with or without pheromones, lure trapping, and training of crop workers to identify and report problems. Recording these data helps, over time, to define economic thresholds.
In addition to monitoring traps it is very important to check the fruits regularly as they begin to ripen. Monitoring should continue right up until harvest and beyond.
Monitoring of natural enemies should be done alongside pests to enable informed decisions on control measures needed.
|
9.3 Direct plant protection method
|
Where indirect plant protection measures are not sufficient to prevent a problem and forecasts and threshold values indicate a need to intervene with direct plant protection measures, priority must be given to:
- Those measures which have the minimum impact on human health, non-target organisms and the environment.
- Biological, biotechnical* and physical methods must be preferred above chemical methods if they provide satisfactory control.
*: Biotechnical control methods are defined in applied entomology as highly specific procedures that influence the behavior or development of pests without direct biocidal activity, such as mating disruption, deterrents, sterile insect technique.
Control method to be used if available, permitted and effective, e.g.
- Biopesticides (e.g. Bacillus thuringiensis, Beauvaria bassiana).
- Semiochemicals (e.g. Pheromone mating disruption)
- Botanicals (e.g. plant extract)
- Entomopathogenic nematodes (e.g. Steinernema spp., Heterorhabditis spp.) and fungi (e.g. Beauveria spp., Metarhizium anisopliae) for soil-borne pests (e.g. vine weevil, slugs, Melolontha spp. and others)
- Antagonistic / mycoparasitic fungi such as entomopathogenic fungi (Metarhizium anisopliae) for some typical pests of protected crops (e.g. Tetranychus urticae, Trialeurodes vaporariorum and thrips),
- Trichoderma spp. for root rots or Gliocladium catenulatumfor Botrytis spp. Control.
- Predatory mites against phytophagous mites, e.g. Phytoseiidae.
- Predatory mites and predatory insects such as Orius spp., against thrips.
- Predators (Chrysoperla, Aphidoletes, hoverflies) and parasitoids against aphids for protected crops.
- Coleopterans, such as Atheta coriaria (efficient in protected crop), for insects' stages in the soil.
|
Weed management should be achieved, as far as possible, by non-chemical methods.
In protected crops, insect-proof nets against pests are recommended, especially when the pressure is high (e.g. Drosophila suzukii).
In open field crops, predators (e.g. Chrysoperla) and parasitoids against aphids are recommended although efficacy could vary.
The application of predators and parasites should focus on all life stages of pests, for example thrips can be targeted on leaves and in the soil.
Consider the use of Trichopria in the margins of crops for Drosophila suzukii control, early season.
|
9.3.1 Restrictive use of pesticides
|
IP guidelines must (see 8.1.3.d) classify pesticides (to be used for the key pests, diseases and weeds) in three categories: 'permitted' (green list), 'permitted with restrictions' (yellow list) and 'not permitted' (red list) based upon±
- Their toxicity to man
- Their toxicity to key natural enemies
- Their toxicity to other non-target organisms
- Their pollution potential for the environment (soil, water, air)
- Their ability to stimulate pests and diseases
- Their selectivity
- Their persistence
- Their potential to develop resistance in target
- Incomplete or missing information
- The necessity of use.
Regularly updated data on the eco-toxicological profiles of pesticides are compiled by IOBC cf. toolbox).
All agrochemicals used must fulfil the basic requirements of GAP.
- The plant protection product applied must be officially approved for the target, as indicated on the product label, or for officially approved off-label uses.
- In countries that have no official registration schemes yet, reference is made to the FAO Code of Conduct on the Distribution and Use of Pesticides.
- All pesticide applications must comply with the statutory conditions regarding the specific crop, maximum permitted total dose, maximum number of treatments, spray intervals and pre-harvest interval, as indicated on the product label or authorised off-label uses.
- Since label doses are maximum doses approved by the registration authorities, reduced dosages are possible, (especially in herbicides).
Chemical soil disinfection is not allowed.
Based on the general criteria, the following categorization of certain pesticides and pesticide groups is established and may require updating with the development of new products.
Not Permitted*
- Plant growth regulators.
- Organochlorine pesticides.
- Persistent (DT50 > three months), toxic or ground-water polluting residual herbicides including triazines.
- Diquat, Paraquat.
- Persistent or phytoseiid mite toxic OP insecticides.
- Pyrethroid insecticides and pyrethroid acaricides. (1)
Permitted with Restrictions
- Non-persistent (DT50 < three months), non-toxic, non-ground water polluting residual herbicides (maximum of one dose-equivalent/annum).
- Benzimidazole fungicides (maximum of one application/year, except on raspberry a maximum of two applications per annum as directed sprays to control cane blight only).
- Other fungicide groups with risk of resistance development (including EBIs, dicarboximides and QOLs) maximum of three applications per group/year alternating different active ingredients.
- Acaricides for control of spider mite (maximum of 1 application per pesticide resistance group /year).
- OP insecticides of short persistence and low toxicity to phytoseiid predatory mites (maximum of 2 applications/year).
*The list of "Not permitted" and "permitted with restrictions" still contains groups of active ingredients no longer allowed in European union; if these groups are still allowed outside Europe than these rules must be followed.
Note (1) as a short-term measure, whilst research is undertaken to identify more selective control methods synthetic pyrethroid insecticides may be used in the following circumstances:
- Maximum of one application/year in emergencies, if no alternatives are available. In case of demonstrated damages provoked by Drosophila suzukii, and under same conditions as above, a maximum of two applications/year is permitted as a specific short-term measure.
- IP programmes, which permit the use of pyrethroids, must have an active research effort to identify alternatives that are more favourable.
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection on strawberry
- Naturally occurring phytoseiid, predatory mites, reduce populations of spider mites, tarsonemid mites and thrips and must be conserved. Use of pesticides harmful to them must be avoided.
- Where application of a harmful pesticide cannot be avoided, effects may be alleviated by downward-directed spraying to reduce deposits on the undersides of leaves where the predatory mites occur mainly and/or making additional releases after the application has been deemed non-toxic.
- The predatory mite, Phytoseiulus persimilis, or another appropriate species must be introduced for biological control of two-spotted spider mite on protected crops (in tunnels etc.).
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection on cane fruits
- Predatory mites must be conserved in field crops and Phytoseiulus persimilis, or another suitable species, used for biological control in protected crops.
- Byturus tomentosus must be monitored regularly by using white sticky traps or with non-sticky bucket traps enhanced with attractant lures including eventual use for mass trapping.
- The raspberry clearwing moth, Pennisetia hylaeiformis and in blackberry, Synanthedon vespiformis must be monitored with pheromone traps. Infested shoots must be pruned and removed from the plantation.
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection of bush fruits
- The currant clearwing moth, Synanthedon tipuliformis, must be monitored with pheromone traps. Infested shoots must be pruned and removed from the plantation.
- Blackcurrant crops must be closely inspected for blackcurrant gall mite galls during the dormant period when they are easily visible and all infested plant material must be removed from the plantation and destroyed. Crops must also be inspected for symptoms of reversion disease immediately before flowering and all infected bushes must be grubbed and destroyed.
|
The use of reduced dosages is recommended wherever possible in accordance with national documentation, experience and legislation.
In Europe EPPO standards are also used as references.
- The occurrence of pesticide residues on fruits at harvest should be further minimised by maximising safe-to-harvest intervals.
- Spray applications should be localised to parts of plantations where damaging infestation is present.
- Adoption of anti-resistance strategies for the at-risk pesticides is strongly recommended.
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection on strawberry
- Entomopathogenic nematodes and fungi, where available, should be used to control vine weevil and other soil pests on protected crops.
- Botrytis cinerea infections on strawberry and other soft fruits can be prevented with an early covering of tunnels and /or the regular use of the antagonistic fungus Gliocladium.
- Orius spp. or suitable predatory mirids should be used to control western flower thrips on protected crops.
- Drosophila suzukii (spotted-wing drosophila) selective insecticides must be used where necessary.
Note: At the time of the definition of the present guideline, D. suzukii is a new pest in Europe and integrated control strategies (such as insect-proof net or biological control, high temperatures at the end of the crop under tunnels as a sanitation measure) are still to be defined. For these reasons, a specific exception is admitted for non-selective insecticide use (see 9.3.1).
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection on cane fruits
- To prevent and control the development of cane diseases the following cultural methods should be applied
i) early removal of infected and superfluous fruiting canes, ii) removal of fruiting canes immediately after harvest, iii) reduction of nitrogen fertilisers rates, iv) drip irrigation should be used in preference to sprinkler and micro-sprinkler systems. - Injurious mirids including Lygus rugulipennis and Lygocoris pabulinus should also be monitored using pheromone traps.
Additional requirements for integrated plant protection of bush fruits
- Branches and stems infected with canker and wood diseases should also be removed and the pruning wounds protected protected with an appropriate product.
- Currant and gooseberry shoots infected with powdery mildew (Sphaerotheca mors-uvae and Microsphaera grossulariae) should be removed to reduce inoculum for the next growing season.
- In blueberry production, organic mulch with bark, wood chips or sawdust is commonly used. Take into account that it can be a dangerous inoculum source of root rot pathogens, Armillaria spp. in particular.
|
9.3.2 Resistance management
|
Where the risk of resistance against a plant protection measure is known and where the level of pests, diseases or weeds requires repeated application of plant protection products in the crops, IP guidelines and IRAC / HRAC/ FRAC** have to provide clear recommendations or mandatory requests for an anti-resistance strategy to maintain the effectiveness of the products.
**:
- IRAC = Insecticide resistance action committee
- HRAC = Herbicide resistance action committee
- FRAC = fungicide resistance action committee
| |
9.4 Lists to be compiled as part of IP guidelines
|
IP guidelines must establish for each crop:
- A restrictive list of key pests, diseases and weeds that are economically important and require regular control measures in the region / crop concerned.
- A list of the most important known site-specific natural antagonist(s), with information on their importance in each crop. The protection and augmentation of at least 2 antagonists must be mentioned in advanced as a desirable objective sustainable production systems.
- A list of preventive and highly selective direct control measures to be used in the IP program (“green list”). See explanations and examples in the IOBC-WPRS Tool Box.
- A list of pesticides to be used with restrictions (“yellow list”): A selected group of plant protection products that do not qualify for the “green list” but should be available to the grower despite certain negative aspects, (especially for reasons of resistance management or earmarked for exceptionally difficult cases). These listed products are permitted only for precisely identified uses with clearly defined restrictions.
| |
9.5 Application and recording of pesticides
|
All pesticide applications must be registered with name, date, crop-pest / crop- disease combination, dosage and field identification where applied.
Buffer zones of adequate size between treated crop areas and sensitive off-crop areas, (surface water, springs, ecological infrastructures), must be observed, (see point 2.6).
The official pre-harvest intervals to minimise pesticide residues must be followed and should, if possible, be extended. They must be recorded for all applications of crop protection product and evidence should be provided that they have been observed. In situations with continuous harvesting, systems must be in place in the field to ensure that safety rules are sufficiently followed (e.g. warning signals).
Spraying during windy weather conditions when wind velocity is exceeding 5m/sec, is not allowed.
Application of pesticides toxic to pollinators is prohibited during the flowering period to avoid sublethal effects and mortality of pollinators.
|
It is strongly recommended that the application of pesticides is limited to the smallest possible area (e.g. band spraying, spot treatments, field and site specific localized treatment).
The use of best application techniques available to minimize drift and loss is highly recommended.
Small untreated areas, (zero treatment or "spray windows"), should be maintained in each crop and in each major plot/field except for arthropod pests, diseases and weeds declared as "highly dangerous/ contagious" by national authorities or in cases with high infectious pests or diseases.
Perennial crops: The use of methods to calculate the right dose of pesticides and spray volume to be applied as a function of the plant growth stage and canopy architecture - such as for instance the TRV (Tree Row Volume) or the LWA (Leaf Wall Area) methods – is highly recommended. Always explore this keeping in mind the specific properties of each pesticide-active ingredient.
|
9.6 Efficient and safe storage and handling of pesticides
|
The basic requirements of Good Agricultural Practice (GAP) with respect to storage (9.6.1), safe handling application and training (9.6.2) and disposal of surplus mix, obsolete pesticides and empty containers (9.6.3), must be fulfilled and outlined in IP guidelines.
| |
9.6.1 Storage
|
Pesticides must be stored in accordance to legal regulations, in a locked room and separated from other materials. Keys and access to the pesticide store must be limited to workers with formal training in the handling of pesticides. Pesticides must only be stored in their original package.
| |
9.6.2 Safe handling, application and training
|
There must be adequate facilities for measuring, mixing and filling the products.
Adequate emergency facilities, such as running water, eyewash facilities, first aid box and emergency procedures, must be provided to deal with potential operator contamination.
Operators must have appropriate protective clothing and equipment for all operations involving chemicals.
All sprayer operators must have appropriate training and hold, where relevant, the appropriate certificate of competence.
| |
9.6.3 Disposal of surplus mix, obsolete pesticides and empty containers
|
Surplus mix or tank washings must either be sprayed onto a designated untreated part of the crop or disposed of by a registered waste contractor or applied in a biodegradation unit.
The safe disposal of spare pesticides must be planned and recorded. They must only be disposed of through an approved chemical waste contractor. Empty pesticide containers must be rinsed with water three times and the rinse water returned to the spray tank. Empty containers must not be re-used but should be crushed or perforated to prevent re-use.
|
Under normal circumstances surplus spray mix should not occur. However, if surplus should occur, disposal must comply with local regulations. Applications onto designated fallow land should demonstrate that this is legal practice and that there is no risk of surface water contamination.
|
9.7 Spraying equipment (pesticides) and technique
|
The basic requirements of Good Agricultural Practice (GAP) with respect to the operation and maintenance of spray equipment must be fulfilled and outlined in IP guidelines.
The equipment must be kept in a good state of repair. Adequate functioning of the equipment must be verified before each treatment. A thorough technical service of the equipment, (especially manometers and nozzles), should follow the national rules and obligations.
Equipment must be verified every 4 year (3 years from 2021) or according to the national guidelines by a competent organisation for correct operation and calibration.
The use of aircraft and helicopters is forbidden, except for situations where access to the plot is impossible because of exceptional weather conditions, or if plot topography allows no other way of spraying.
Radial flow air assisted sprayers traditionally used for tree and bush fruit spraying are often inefficient and generate high levels of spray drift. Wherever possible spraying equipment and spraying conditions minimising the health risk of the operator and drift must be preferred and tractors must be fitted with a cab.
The spray impact on the environment can be minimised by the proper calculation of the amount of product needed per ha.
|
The use of drift reduction techniques with the least drift and pesticide loss should be encouraged whilst maintaining efficacy.
When new sprayers are purchased, transverse flow designs or tunnel sprayers should be selected where possible.
Sprayers should be properly and regularly calibrated with and hold the relevant certification.
Spray efficacy and deposit should be monitored and nozzle direction adjusted to avoid spray drift.
|
9.8 Pesticide residues
|
Legal requirements of pesticide residues must be fulfilled.
| |